Press "Enter" to skip to content

Belarus forced down a plane in Minsk while Europe watches paralysed

On Sunday afternoon, May 23rd, a Ryanair plane with around 170 passengers on board that took off from Athens, Greece, and was supposed to land in Vilnius, Lithuania, was diverted by Belarusian Air traffic controllers and ordered to land in Minsk due to a potential security risk aboard the plane. What no one knew prior to landing: the potential “security threat” Belarus hinted at was the 26-year-old Belarusian blogger and regime opponent, Roman Protasevich – who may present a threat to the Belarusian regime, but no one else. 

Upon landing in Minsk, where no bomb or any other sort of security threat was found, the well-known dissident was arrested and is likely to face the death penalty, he allegedly told a fellow passenger.  

Stay up to Date – Subscribe to our newsletter.

As expected, the reckless act by Belarusian authorities sparked outrage in Europe and beyond, EU officials calling it an act of state terrorism. A special EU meeting will be held on Monday to discuss the May 23, 2021 incident and possible further sanctions on Belarus, adding to the ones already in place. A “strategic debate on Russia” is also on the agenda.

The swift decision to hold a summit on the situation in Belarus and discuss potential penalties is the right move from the EU that may demonstrate the capacity to act fast and use what the EU understands as “force” when needed. This is an opportunity for the EU to demonstrate its capacity to act swiftly and prove its ability to speak the language of power. It also offers a chance to show that the EU can take a stand in delicate situations and is quick to act, despite being constituted by 27 member states that all have different interests and political priorities. 

After a missed opportunity to support the Belarusian opposition effectively last summer and its failure to send a clear signal that human rights violations in a partner country 1 are not tolerated, it is about time that the EU stands up for its values and defends them – also beyond its borders and in partner countries. 

Protests in Belarus, 2020
Protests in Belarus, 2020

And yet, it remains doubtful whether a swift decision on Belarus will be taken. Foreign policy decisions in the EU require unanimity, which is rarely granted in today’s EU. One primary reason for it being the diverging interests between the member states, and in particular, some countries’ foreign policy outlook and priorities.

In the past weeks, the EU was unable to agree on a joint statement in various cases due to Hungary vetoing statements on Hong Kong and China as well as on the recent escalation of tensions between Israel and Palestine.
It thus seems evident that also in the case of Belarus, there will be long, though discussion, and it is somewhat questionable whether any joint statement that does not sit well with certain heads of state will be adopted. At best, the EU might put out a watered-down comment that will have mild, if any, effects.

Apart from a unified statement that the EU is supposed to put forward, the block will also discuss sanctions on Belarus, in addition to the ones already in place, on Monday evening. Sanctions are one of the few “hard”, more coercive tools in the EU’s foreign policy toolbox and are thus among the limited options to respond to this type of behaviour. However, given their often symbolic nature and little effects, it is unlikely that more added sanctions on the country will have any positive effect and bring about significant behavioural change in the Belarusian regime. The EU could only make new sanctions more powerful if they are harder in their nature by, for example, targeting pro-Lukashenko oligarchs and specific industries who have previously been spared.

The EU must also not underestimate the role Russia might have played in the forced landing in Minsk. According to a report by Reuters, “air defenses of Belarus were closely integrated with those of Russia”. Hence, it is unlikely that Russia did not know about the plan to force down the Ryanair passenger plane beforehand. Furthermore, four more passengers allegedly stayed behind in Minsk together with Roman Protasevich and his girlfriend, all four being Russian citizens. This leaves the impression that it was in fact a Russian-Belarusian coordinated act.

The EU should thus consider targeting Russia as well in its response to this unacceptable act. What is likely is that any isolated response on Belarus will only drive it from the European sphere further into the arms of Russia.

Hope remains that all EU member states jointly agree that this dangerous course of action by Belarusian authorities needs to be addressed and punished adequately. In addition, the European Union needs to seriously deliberate about how it can effectively support and safeguard the democratic forces and opposition in Belarus to help the country on its path from Lukashenko’s dictatorship to a stable democracy. EU member states should keep in mind that, as once perfectly put by the former Lithuanian foreign minister, “It is not enough to judge, to assess, to condemn, there should be actions”.

Lastly, while the EU deliberates on the response to this incident, the following questions should also be considered: If this can happen on European territory to a plane that was bound to travel from one EU member state to another – how safe are dissident journalists in Europe? What does it say about the protection of EU values? And how can we effectively safeguard values such as human rights and freedom of speech in wider Europe?

Sources

Der Standard (2021): Belarus zwingt Ryanair-Jet zu Landung in Minsk und nimmt Regimegegner fest, https://www.derstandard.at/story/2000126869155/flugzeug-mit-oppositionellem-blogger-zur-landung-in-minsk-gezwungen?ref=rec

Duxbury, C. (2021): EU too slow to help Belarus, says Lithuania, Politico, https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-too-slow-to-help-belarus-says-lithuania-foreign-minister-linas-linkevicius-alexander-lukashenko/

European Council/Council of the European Union (2021): Belarus: EU prolongs sanctions for a year, https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2021/02/25/belarus-eu-prolongs-sanctions-for-a-year/

European Council/Council of the European Union (2021): Special meeting of the European Council, 24-25 May 2021, https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/meetings/european-council/2021/05/24-25/

Rettmann, A. (2021): Lukashenko to face EU sanctions after Ryanair’ hijacking’, EUObserver, https://euobserver.com/world/151924

Roth, A. & Boffey, D. (2021): Belarus KGB believed to be on plane forced to land in Minsk, says Ryanair CEO, The Guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/may/24/belarus-seizure-blogger-ryanair-flight-us-outcry

Sytan, A. & (2021): Belarus forces airliner to land and arrests opponent, sparking U.S. and European outrage, Reuters, https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/belarus-forces-vilnius-bound-ryanair-plane-land-detain-blogger-2021-05-23/

Troianovski, A. & Nechepurenko, I. (2021): Belarus Forces Down Plane to Seize Dissident; Europe Sees’ State Hijacking’, The New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/23/world/europe/ryanair-belarus.html

Troianovski, A. (2021): Six people on flight, including journalist, remained in Belarus, The New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/24/world/europe/six-people-on-flight-including-journalist-remained-in-belarus.html

Twitter (2021): Balász Csekö Satus, https://twitter.com/balazscseko/status/1396580563985866754 

Twitter (2021): Kateryna_Kruk Status, https://twitter.com/Kateryna_Kruk/status/1396553036600856582

Twitter (2021): Timothy Snider Status, https://twitter.com/TimothyDSnyder/status/1396549642695946241


Footnotes
  1. Belarus is one of six countries to participate in the Eastern Partnership Initiative [>]

Does Turkey still have a place in NATO?

Turkey has had a long-standing relationship with Europe and the West. Its integration into the transatlantic alliance in 1952 was perceived as being of strategic importance to Washington, as it covered the south-eastern flank of the alliance’s borders. Under the leadership of Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Turkey is pursuing an aggressive foreign policy aimed at challenging the liberal international order, which has considerably alienated Turkey’s Western allies.

The Real Culprit: Globalization as A Cause of Terrorism

In the 21st century, terrorism has been one of the most prominent national and international security and defense problems. While terrorism is a centuries-old issue, it has gained prominence since the massive improvement of technology from the mid-20th century onward and has become a force used by state and non-state actors and poses significant problems for democratic and authoritative regimes alike. In many ways, terrorism and its ability to be conducted anywhere, at any time, has been aided seriously by globalization.

The Nuclear Ban is Here – A Hopeful Sign for Nuclear Disarmament? 

The Treaty on the Prevention of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW) enters into force on 22 January 2021. This means for the first time since the invention of nuclear weapons, their use, threat of use, development, production, manufacture, acquisition, possession, stockpiling, transfer, stationing, or the installation of nuclear arms on a signatory’s territory by another country will become illegal under international law.

Jair Bolsonaro – Person of the year in organized crime and corruption?

The nomination of the Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro for the 2020 corrupt person of the year award is questionable. Other prominent but controversial political leaders such as Recep Erdogan, Xi Jinping, and Alexander Lukashenko certainly were better candidates and could very well be given the infamous award.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *